[fredrian.seven]

Originally Posted by Ardiey11

pandangan pribadi saya tentang ini SAF tidak bisa di salahkan.
Krn kita tau kualitas pemain yg ada SAF bisa merengkuh juara, permasalahan yg di hadapi Moyes saat itu menurut saya ego besar pemain veteran yg "kurang" mendukung kedatangan pelatih baru. Terlihat dr betapa tidak akurnya antara Rio dan Moyes, dan bisa jadi dari sini sedikit banyak bisa mempengaruhi rekan tim yg lain. Praktis cm Fellaini yg benar2 bermain sepenuh hati u/ moyes yg notabennya jadi anak emas di club sebelumnya (meski low perform), dan Juan Mata pembelian pertengahan musim yg ingin membuktikan diri setelah kurang dapat kesempatan di tim sebelumnya.
Dan bila di lempar lagi jauh ke musim '12/'13 saat SAF pensiun dg perform pemain United sekarang, semakin tak masuk akal bila ingin menyalahkan SAF. Dari kaca mata saya, 1. Kesalahan kebijakan transfer pemain MU. 2. Terlalu monoton formasi yg di miliki LvG. 3. Tidak ada mental pemain yg mampu mengubah arah permainan.
*SruputKopi*

yang ane warnai... itu berkaitan sama poin 3 tulisan pakde Durham.

3) Ferguson left no legacy. He left behind a team of title winners, but it was also a squad of players who were either ageing, dependent on Fergie, or disillusioned.

No foundations for a rebuild were put in place and Sir Alex has escaped scrutiny for that error because of his undoubted greatness. There was no recruitment plan or structure.

He departed, David Gill went too, and the club has been flailing around in the dark ever since. The first signs of this came when United tried to sign Leighton Baines and Marouane Fellaini for £24m, and ended up paying £28m for Fellaini who can try all he likes, but he will never be good enough for Manchester United.

It's a preposterous sum for a player with no prospect of development, and limited scope of talent. The trophy count of a manager is important, but so is his legacy, and Fergie failed with the latter.

The biggest criticism is how he left the club after waving a white flag to the 'noisy neighbours'. Manchester City, on and off the field, are leaving United behind. Fergie was in a hurry when he knew he couldn't put up a fight. He left United floundering.

aku sih setuju sama pakde Durham.