FA (Referee) vs United

[Eryk EQ]

Saya pikir mmg ad sentuhan ringan dr Caulker yg menyebabkan Wazza kehilangan keseimbangan, tp apa sentuhan tsb cukup utk menjadi penalti? Who knows. Posisi hakim garis saat itu lbh dekat dan bs menghasilkan putusan yg mendekati kebenaran
Ini agak mirip dengan sentuhan Agger pd Berba d FA Cup saat United mng 1-0 via Penalti Giggs. Iya, saat itu kita dpt penalti krna sentuhan ringan yg serupa
Just IMHO

[rondwisan]

Opa Fergie udah nyerahin jawaban (keberatan) atas "pertanyaan" FA, dari comment kerasnya pada hakim garis di WHL minggu malam lalu. FA akan mempelajari dan memberikan putusan pada selasa sore lusa
___________________________

FA ponder Fergie punishment over United boss's blast at linesman after Rooney denied penalty at White Hart Lane
Simon Stone, Press Association - 24 January 2013


The Football Association has received Sir Alex Ferguson's observations about his post-match comments at Tottenham last Sunday.

Ferguson submitted the information prior to the 6pm deadline, the FA confirmed.

Now the FA has until Tuesday evening to decide whether to formally charge Ferguson.

Ferguson spoke out following the 1-1 draw at White Hart Lane, when United conceded an injury-time equaliser after Wayne Rooney's penalty claim was rejected by referee Chris Foy.


Furious Fergie: Sir Alex was critical of linesman Simon Beck after his side's draw at Spurs

However, it was assistant Simon Beck who bore the brunt of Ferguson's ire, with the Scot's discontent with the linesman dating back to April 2010 when he failed to spot Didier Drogba was in an offside position as he scored a crucial goal for Chelsea at Old Trafford.

'He had a really poor game,' said Ferguson at the weekend. 'There was no way the linesman was going to give that - he gave them everything.

'It was a clear decision. And he was 10 yards away, maybe 12 yards away from the incident and he doesn't give it. And yet he gave everything else.

'I am disappointed with him [Beck] - we have not had a good record with him.

'With Chelsea a couple of years back, he gave onside to Didier Drogba and he was three yards offside. You remember these things because it is in important games and that was an important game.'

[kingherooney]

Bukti otentik buat para hater bahwa united bukan anak emas FA dan sering kali keputusan-keputusan yang tidak fair didapat united.
Maju terus opa, kita selalu dibelakang mu....

[Redsbusby]

Wah threadnya masih eksis. We'll see.. mari tengok bentar ke belakang.. ini artikel udah 3 bulan lalu gw baca, sempet saling bahas ama si @troy_andreas berasal dr seorang pendukung liverpool (so far) ttg keputusan wasit selama 20 tahun terakhir berkaitan dgn anggapan banyak haters yg merasa bahwa Fergie punya indra keenam untuk ngontrol keputusan wasit ditambah musim ini aja dr laga liverpool, chelsea, city semua dihubungin dgn wasit (apalagi pas kita menang 2-1 di anfield bulan september tahun lalu / mark halsey)

Menurut sumber yg ngakunya bernama Jaimie Anwar ini dia ngambil data menurut data seluruh keputusan wasit era PremierLeague 1992 sampe akhir tahun 2012 diliat dr jumlah kartu kuning, merah, dan penalti (karena dianggap kontroversi biasanya dimulai dari keputusan ini) hasilnya:

- United mendapat lebih banyak kartu kuning dan kartu merah dibanding Liverpool
- Pool mendapat lebih banyak pinalti di Old Trafford ketimbang penalti United di Anfield
- Total, United mendapat kartu lebih banyak di tiap laga dibanding Liverpool.

jadi gw rasa ga ada lah yg namanya konspirasi apalagi bwt rival utama. Kalo emang konspirasi kenapa sampe detik ini ga ada yg ngangkat layaknya calciopoli atau Scommessopoli, dll?

jealous mah jealous aja jgn banyak alesan Mungkin ada beberapa keputusan yg dianggap gak seharusnya dikasih gt aja bwt United, tp gw yakin klub yg didukung para haters lainnya jg pernah berkali2 dapet durian runtuh begituan :p kalo udah begini mah jgn melulu liat siapa yg diuntungin, bolehlah kita intip kualitas wasitnya. Mau tekel buruk atau enggak kan terserah sudut pandang mereka mau kasih foul atau kartu,.. well thats football.. IMRHO

[rondwisan]

OOT dikit ya ...
Jadi inget match LFC vs Reading bbrp musim lalu (saat masih ditangani Steve Coppel), home and away LFC dpt penalti yg enggak banget deh ..., cuman dari corner kick gitu, trus Gerrard loncat nubruk pemain lawan n jatuh, dapet deh penalti ...., terlepas sengaja apa ndak, diving or not Ya intinya gk cuman United yg 'bisa' dhujat selalu diuntungkan wasit

[rondwisan]

ManUtd.com - 29/01/2013 17:01
FA charge for Sir Alex



The Football Association published the following statement this afternoon (Tuesday) on www.thefa.com:

"The FA has today charged Sir Alex Ferguson in relation to post-match media comments made following Manchester United’s game at Tottenham Hotspur on Sunday 20 January 2013.

"It is alleged the Manchester United manager breached FA Rule E3 in that he implied that the match official was motivated by bias.

"Ferguson has until 16:00 on Friday 1 February 2013 to respond to the charge."

[rondwisan]

Ferguson denies FA charge
ESPN - February 1, 2013


The Football Association have confirmed that Manchester United manager Sir Alex Ferguson has denied a charge of misconduct and requested a paper hearing.

Ferguson criticised assistant referee Simon Beck's performance following the 1-1 draw with Tottenham on Sunday, January 20.

The FA said in a statement: "Sir Alex Ferguson has denied an FA charge of misconduct in relation to post-match media comments made following Manchester United's game at Tottenham Hotspur on Sunday 20 January 2013.



Sir Alex Ferguson believes Manchester United were denied a penalty against Tottenham


"It is alleged the Manchester United manager breached FA Rule E3 in that he implied that the match official was motivated by bias.

"Ferguson has requested a paper hearing, the date of which will be set in due course."

Speaking after the Premier League game against Spurs, Ferguson was angered by the decision not to award United a penalty for a foul on Wayne Rooney.

He said: "It was a clear decision. And he [Beck] was 10, maybe 12 yards away from the incident and he doesn't give it. And yet he gave everything else."

Ferguson also claimed United had "history" with Beck following the official's failure to rule out a Didier Drogba goal for offside at Old Trafford in 2010, in a match that proved pivotal in that season's title race.

"There was no way we were going to get a decision from [Beck]," Ferguson continued.

Ferguson did not discuss the issue at his press conference on Friday, although last week he said he suspected the matter has become personal.

"That is what I have put in my letter exactly. But you never know the FA," he said. "We are high profile and the profile of me is such that the FA naturally panic as soon as the press criticise them.

"I think that is what you will find. That is why they have sent me a letter.Whether I think it is unfair or not doesn't matter to them really at this point. I just think it is more about me than what I have said."

[Redsbusby]

Masih ngga ngerti apa sih dasar FA ngasih peringatan? Bukannya negur orang kalo jelas2 nenek nyimeng aja bisa ngeliat kesalahan itu, sah2 aja ya?

Jelas banget itu pelanggaran dan Ferguson hanya minta keadilan gak berlebihan. Kadang FA terlalu angkuh untuk ngakuin kekurangan kualitas wasitnya..

[iamsetia]

Originally Posted by rondwisan

Ferguson also claimed United had "history" with Beck following the official's failure to rule out a Didier Drogba goal for offside at Old Trafford in 2010, in a match that proved pivotal in that season's title race.

artikel gambar dr bawah sumbernya dr fourfour 2 gini:


dan diakhir musimnya gini..

memenangkan liga dgn selisih 1 point!

Man Utd P32 72pts
Chelsea P32 71pts
Man Utd 1-2 Chelsea (April 3, 2010)


Sir Alex Ferguson has conceded that this game, in between crashing out of the Champions League to Bayern Munich, cost the title. Chelsea overtook United thanks to an arguably offside strike from Didier Drogba. Chelsea won the title by a point. Same again, Didi?

Read more: www.dailymail.co.uk

[iamsetia]

lanjutin lagi ah, artikel tentang SAF vs FA yg lagi panas2nya..

sumber: dailymail.co.uk

Fergie DENIES charge over blast at linesman who turned down Rooney penalty claim at Spurs

By Chris Wheeler
PUBLISHED: 17:13 GMT, 1 February 2013 | UPDATED: 20:19 GMT, 1 February 2013



Sir Alex Ferguson has taken on the FA by deciding to fight allegations that he questioned the integrity of a match official.


Ferguson has been charged with misconduct over comments he made after Manchester United's draw with Tottenham at White Hart Lane last month.


The Old Trafford boss refused to discuss the issue at his weekly press conference, saying it had been 'taken care of', and the FA later confirmed that he has denied the charge.

Fuming: Ferguson was furious with Beck for missing Caulker's trip on Rooney

The case will now be heard before an independent commission, possibly next week, although Ferguson will not appear in person. United are expected to make a written submission.



The FA decided that Ferguson 'implied that the match official was motivated by bias' when he criticised assistant Simon Beck for not flagging for a penalty when Wayne Rooney went down under a challenge from Steven Caulker.

Ferguson claimed United 'were never going to get a decision' from Beck and that 'he gave them everything else'.

If found guilty, he is most likely to face a fine, although a touchline ban remains a possibility. His last two suspensions were the result of comments about officials.
Meanwhile, Ferguson insisted that his players will not get carried away over the prospect of going 10 points clear of Manchester City if they win at Fulham today.

Hot water: The United boss has been summoned before the FA


Late twist: Ferguson was even more unhappy after Clint Dempsey (left) scored Tottenham's added-time leveller

But he backed United to win the title. after the disappointment of seeing their advantage evaporate last season.

'What happened last season happened,' he added. 'We didn't enjoy that. This season we should take care of it because we have the experience.

'There's a long way to go, 14 games, and a lot can happen. We're not certainties. We were 11 points clear of Arsenal one year and lost the league, and we were 12 points behind Newcastle and won it. It's an unremitting league. If you make mistakes you get punished. I don't expect my players to become complacent.

'The most important thing is to keep our feet on the ground and try to win our game at Fulham. We'll see where that takes us.'

United stiker Wayne Rooney has revealed that it was his decision, not Ferguson's, to stop taking penalties for the club.

He has missed two spot-kicks for United this season, and seven since the start of 2010, and told the manager following his miss against West Ham in the FA Cup third round replay that he wished to pass the duties to Robin van Persie.

Rooney told MUTV: 'At a club like this, to miss two penalties and not hit the target wasn't good enough.'