FA (Referee) vs United

[zudomiriku]

'Hukuman untuk Sir Alex Terlalu Ringan'
Narayana Mahendra Prastya - detiksport



London - Hukuman yang diberikan oleh FA kepada manajer Manchester United Sir Alex Ferguson dinilai mengecewakan oleh serikat wasit. Sanksi tersebut dinilai terlalu ringan.

Ferguson dihukum empat laga usai mengeluarkan komentar pedas terhadap wasit Alan Willey yang memimpin pertandingan MU vs Sunderland.

Dengan sanksi tersebut maka Setan Merah tidak akan didampingi Ferguson ketika menghadapi Everton dan Portsmouth. Sementara dua partai lainnya masih ditangguhkan sampai akhir musim 2010/11.

Dua sanksi yang ditangguhkan tersebut bersifat hukuman percobaan. Artinya, hukuman akan berlaku otomatis jika Fergie ketahuan bersalah lagi atas kasus serupa sebelum akhir musim 2010/11.

Hukuman ini dinilai oleh serikat wasit Prospect terlalu ringan. "Dari pandangan kami keputusan FA mengecewakan. FA punya kesempatan untuk menciptakan sesuatu yang menjadi titik tolak dan mereka tidak menggunakannya," demikian diungkapkan Alan Leighton dari Prospect, diberitakan AFP.

Prospect menilai hukuman ini tidak memberikan efek yang tepat untuk manajer-manajer yang lain.

"Penilaian kami bukan didasari dendam pribadi terhadap Sir Alex. Namun Sir Alex memiliki kedudukan khusus dalam kompetisi ini."

"Bila hukuman yang dijatuhkan tampak terlalu ringan, maka manajer lain akan berpikir bahwa apa yang dia katakan itu tidak di luar batas," tuntas Leighton.

[drivemein]

Fergie 'happy' with two-match ban
-Independent.ie-

ALEX FERGUSON is set to forego an appeal against a two-match touchline ban and £20,000 fine after the English Football Association was accused of 'flunking' the Manchester United manager's punishment for questioning the fitness of referee Alan Wiley.

Ferguson was handed a two-match touchline ban -- with two further games suspended until the end of the 2010-11 season -- plus a fine following a two-and-a-half-hour personal hearing in front of an FA regulatory commission in London yesterday.

But that punishment has been described as too lenient by Alan Leighton, national secretary of Prospect, the union which represents referees, and of failing to support the FA's 'Respect' campaign.

Leighton, a vociferous critic of Ferguson since the Wiley controversy erupted, had called for the United manager to be hit with a Uefa-style touchline ban, which would have also prevented him from accessing the team dressing-room on matchdays.

Leighton said: "From our point of view it is disappointing. The Football Association had a chance to make a point and they flunked it. To question the fitness of a referee is to question his ability to do the job and his integrity. We don't think this is sending the right message out to other managers."

Sources close to the United manager have described the Scot as "quite happy" with the outcome, despite the FA breaking with precedent by issuing a touchline ban for post-match comments.

But while Ferguson has until 6pm today to appeal against the punishment, it is understood that he will accept the sanction and serve his ban during the Premier League games against Everton at Old Trafford on November 21 and the fixture against Portsmouth at Fratton Park the following week.

[drivemein]

Wiley could sue Fergie for defamation
-soccernet.espn.go.com-



Alan Wiley could yet sue Sir Alex Ferguson for defamation after the referee union revealed it would discuss possible legal action against the Manchester United manager following comments that earned him a two-match touchline ban.

FA bans Fergie for two games

The FA this week handed Ferguson his ban, plus two further matches suspended and a £20,000 fine for saying Wiley "just wasn't fit enough" to take charge of United's 2-2 draw with Sunderland last month.

Alan Leighton, national secretary for referees' union Prospect, said: "One of the things we are saying is, is there a case these comments are defamatory? I intend to talk to Alan Wiley to see if he wants to sue on the issue.

"We need to take a few steps back and see what has happened here and I would like to see more about the judgement. We never wanted to get lawyers involved in but if referees don't feel they are being protected by the regulatory bodies and someone says something defamatory sooner or later someone is going to take action over it.

"We are going to talk to the relevant authorities to see what it means for the future. I'll also talk to our members. I think there will be a concern this isn't an appropriate way to send a message that these comments were wholly unacceptable.''

Ferguson's ban means he will miss matches at home to Everton and away at Portsmouth.

[fredrian.seven]

Mo nanya...hukuman dilarang mendampingi tim dari pinggir lapangan apa termasuk nggak boleh memberi intruksi di ruang ganti ya?

[Oncy]

Ngga bro, setau gw hanya tdk boleh duduk di bench aja... Ttp bs memberikan isntruksi kpd asistennya dan saat halftime... Kecuali di banned nya tdk boleh hadir di stadion...

[fredrian.seven]

Originally Posted by Oncy

Ngga bro, setau gw hanya tdk boleh duduk di bench aja... Ttp bs memberikan isntruksi kpd asistennya dan saat halftime... Kecuali di banned nya tdk boleh hadir di stadion...

Klo gitu Fergie masih bisa pake jurus hairdryer-nya klo permaenan MU nggak memuaskan pas jeda babak II.

[Red Army]

sempat gak percaya kalo Gergie bakalan di banned
ban di mulai away ke Everton minggu depan & menjamu Portsmouth seminggu kemudian

[sir_otz]

Evans in referees blast
Defender unhappy with officials
Last updated: 13th November 2009

Jonny Evans believes Manchester United have been getting a raw deal off referees this season.

The Northern Ireland international feels the reigning Premier League champions have not been getting the benefit of some 50-50 decisions in recent games.

United boss Sir Alex Ferguson and a number of players were unhappy with a host of decisions given by referee Martin Atkinson during last weekend's defeat at Chelsea.

United were aggrieved Atkinson awarded a foul against Darren Fletcher for a challenge on Ashley Cole in the build-up to Chelsea's winning goal, while they felt Didier Drogbapulled Wes Brown's shirt as John Terryscored the winner.

Evans believes United are having to beat the officials on some occasions to get results.

"We are usually quite good with referees," Evans told Sky Sports News. "I think there are a lot of teams that do a lot of playacting, but I don't think that's the case with Manchester United.
"I think we do try and play fair and not many of us would roll around and try and cheat.

"Sometimes the 50-50 decisions, that you would hope because of that would go in your way, have not been really going our way lately and I think that's what has maybe been disheartening a few of the lads, but that's football.

"Sometimes you have got to beat the referee as well and that is what we are going to try and do."

http://www.skysports.com/story/0,19528,11667_5693379,00.html?

[otonk reddevilz]

Jum'at, 20 November 2009, 06:50 WIB
Preview MU vs Everton
Hukuman Ditangguhkan, Ferguson Dampingi MU

VIVAnews - Kabar gembira buat Manchester United. Hukuman empat laga yang diterima Sir Alex Ferguson belum diberlakukan saat MU menjamu Everton, Sabtu 21 November 2009 nanti.

Ferguson akan tetap memimpin Iblis Merah saat meladeni tim besutan David Moyes di Old Trafford. Seperti yang dilansir Goal, hukuman Ferguson akan ditangguhkan hingga 14 hari sejak hukuman itu dijatuhkan.

Sebelumnya, Ferguson memang telah dijatuhi hukuman larangan mendampingi timnya dalam dua pertandingan tahun ini dan dua lainya di musim kompetisi 2010-2011.

Kehadiran Ferguson ini tentu akan melecut semangat Wayne Rooney cs. Terlebih kekuatan MU juga mendekati sempurna. Hanya John O'Shea yang kabarnya cedera usai membela Irlandia di pertandingan playoff Kualifikasi Piala Dunia.

Di barisan depan, Fergie akan kembali menduetkan Dimitar Berbatov dengan Wayne Rooney. Striker Bulgaria ini mulai pulih dari cedera. Michael Owen juga bisa menjadi solusi jika Berbatov masih belum maksimal.

Sedangkan di barisan pertahanan, Jonny Evans rupanya akan diduetkan dengan Nemanja Vidic setelah Rio Ferdinand masih diragukan. Keduanya akan diapit Patrice Evra dan Wes Brown sebagai bek sayap.

Di barisan tengah Ferguson tentu lebih memiliki banyak pilihan. Ryan Giggs, Nani, Anderson, Gabriel Obertan, Michael Carrick, Darren Fletcher, Paul Scholes dan Antonio Valencia siap diturunkan.

Sejarah pertemuan juga masih berpihak pada tuan rumah. Sejak format berubah menjadi Premier League, MU hanya sekali mengalami kekalahan dari The Toffees di Old Trafford.
• VIVAnews

sumber : http://bola.vivanews.com/news/read/1...on_dampingi_mu

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

nih komisi wasitnya khilaf kayaknya yah...hehehe...baguslah...

[Red Army]

untung United menang terus saat Fergie gak mendampingi di pinggir lapangan, besok2 sabar ya opa, selain gak bagus buat klub juga gak bagus tuk kesehatan kalo sering marah2...